While looking at some other crafty blogs online last night, I found a reference to ArtFire.com. It seems to be a fairly new site that works just like Etsy, except it doesn't charge you to list or sell up to 10 items at a time. It is possible to list more items, but for that you need a paid account with a flat fee of $20 per month. The other major difference is that buyers are not required to register. I can see how this might help attract some customers, but I don't think most people are really bothered by registering on sites online these days. Not a bad site, although I admit I like the look and feel of Etsy a lot more.
Click on the banner on the right side bar to take a look in person!